Lesson 2 of 7 · 2 min read
Carbon has lost the trust of Indigenous peoples
Carbon credits have failed Indigenous peoples. A serious project says so, and sticks to concrete things.
“Listen to Indigenous peoples. Learn from Indigenous peoples.”
In 30 seconds
- The reports presented at the COP describe phantom credits, contracts of 30 to 100 years and revenue captured by intermediaries.
- The UN Special Rapporteur concludes there are structural failures that violate states' human rights obligations.
- In Europe, a company can no longer call itself “carbon neutral” on the basis of offsets.
What we heard
- An investigation cited on stage concluded that the vast majority of forest credits certified by the largest certifier did not match any real reduction. (Carbon markets and the rights of Indigenous peoples)
- The IWGIA report documents communities paid “2 dollars per hectare”, contracts signed in English with incomplete information, and self-declared safeguards. (IWGIA 2026 report: carbon markets and the rights of Indigenous peoples)
- The speakers refuse to propose fixes: reforming these markets would legitimize them. (Carbon markets and the rights of Indigenous peoples)
- In most cases, REDD+ has not benefited Indigenous peoples in the Amazon. (Indigenous solutions for the climate)
- WECAN lists carbon credits, offsets and biodiversity credits among the “false solutions”. (Women leaders of climate action)
What it means
- Promise nothing in tons of CO2: no neutrality, no offsetting.
- Say what you actually fund: a protected forest in a specific place, trained and equipped guardians, services for the villages.
- Short contracts, readable in the community's language, and a “no” that stops everything.
- Do not put a price on any animal or any sacred place.