Lesson 3 of 7 · 2 min read
Consent is a process, not a signature
No consent, no funding. And “no” must always remain a possible answer.
“‘No’ is a complete sentence.”
In 30 seconds
- Free, prior and informed consent (FPIC) is a right, not a formality or an information meeting.
- It is given according to each people's own rules, and it can be withdrawn.
- The obligation also applies to those who provide the money: banks, funds, investors.
What we heard
- Four questions to ask before any project: does it really need to be done? where do land rights stand? where does consent stand? who is accountable if things go wrong? (Indigenous solutions for the climate)
- For large projects, the state must obtain consent, not just consult (Inter-American Court, Saramaka v. Suriname, 2007). (Indigenous solutions for the climate)
- Consultations often turn into theater: committees with no decision-making power, used to legitimize. (Carbon markets and the rights of Indigenous peoples)
- Consent is an ongoing process, where “no” is a valid answer. (Our Collective Futures and Indigenous Navigator)
- The data in reports and contracts must reflect what families think, otherwise consent does not exist. (Rivers, consent and sacred sites)
What it means
- Build into every program the moment when the community can say no, or ask for more time.
- Translate and explain every document in the community's language.
- Give the community the means to negotiate: an advisor or a lawyer of its choice.
- Ask for agreement before recording, and say what the recording is for.
Heard in these sessions
Practical guides
Before talking about carbon
Before raising carbon with a community, know what Indigenous peoples say about it, and promise nothing in tons of CO2.
Four questions before any project in Indigenous territory
The Cultural Survival checklist, to ask before any climate project or climate funding in Indigenous territory.