Lesson 4 of 7 · 2 min read
Who owns the data owns the value
A people's data and knowledge must stay under its control. Otherwise, technology reproduces inequality.
“Who owns the data owns the value.”
In 30 seconds
- First Nations in Canada apply the PCAP principles: ownership, control, access, possession.
- Some maps and some knowledge are sacred: they must never become public.
- Without translation, reports about Indigenous peoples stay out of their reach.
What we heard
- Under the PCAP principles, data stays hosted with Indigenous organizations, and any outside access needs permission. (Our Collective Futures and Indigenous Navigator)
- The Indigenous Navigator uses community-led surveys to document the impact of climate on Indigenous peoples in about thirty countries. In Nepal and Bangladesh: no real consent, no money arriving, no information in Indigenous languages. (Our Collective Futures and Indigenous Navigator)
- In Cambodia, a community mapped its lands with GPS and built a portal to defend its boundaries. (Our Collective Futures and Indigenous Navigator)
- Without local ownership of data, AI reproduces historical inequalities. (Africa, resources and AI)
- In Peru, some weather stations still write their readings on paper: an alert that should arrive ten hours ahead arrives one or two hours ahead. (The digital divide in the Peruvian Amazon)
What it means
- Decide from the start what is public, what stays internal and what is sacred.
- Host the data with the community, or wherever it decides.
- Translate, and use spoken formats when speech is the everyday language.